Institute of Social Anthropology

Staff

Prof. Dr. Charles Heller

Professor Starting Grant

Phone
+41 31 684 6553
E-Mail
charles.heller@unibe.ch
Office
S215
Postal Address
Postal Address
Lerchenweg 36, 3012 Bern
Consultation Hour
Tuesday 2 to 3:30pm

Charles Heller is SNF Professor at the Department of Social Anthropology of the University of Bern where he is leading the “Circumference of Violence research” SNF Starting Grant project (2024-2028) and Director of Research within the Border Forensics investigation agency. He is further affiliated to the University of Bristol as Research Associate. He is a board member of the Mobility & Politics book series and was co-president of the Migreurop network between 2019-2023.

Heller is a transdisciplinary researcher, filmmaker and human rights activist whose work has a long-standing focus on the politics of migration, borders, mediation and the law within and at the borders of Europe. Heller’s research draws on the disciplines of anthropology and geography, but also on arts and architecture-based methodologies, and engages with the study of politics and the law across disciplines.

Heller conducted his PhD thesis at the Centre for Research Architecture, Goldsmiths College, University of London. Its core was constituted by the “Forensic Oceanography” project, which Heller led in collaboration with Lorenzo Pezzani between 2011 and 2021 within the broader Forensic Architecture agency. The Forensic Oceanography project developed new cutting-edge methods to analyse the policies and practices that lead to widespread deaths and violations of migrants’ rights at the EU’s maritime frontier. Through this research Forensic Oceanography has sought to support different nongovernmental actors aiming to contest the EU’s lethal border regime. Heller has contributed in particular to litigation efforts and to launching the WatchTheMed platform, a tool enabling nongovernmental actors to exercise a critical right to look at the EU’s maritime frontier and support migrants during their perilous crossings. Heller’s approach seeks to combine research and practice in transformative and reflexive ways. The knowledge he generates contributes to different forms of nongovernmental practices, and his engagement with these practices allows him in turn to reflect upon their strength, limits and ambivalences in a way that simultaneously contributes to debates both within academia and in the field of nongovernmental practice. Crucial fields of reflection and experimentation for Heller include the critical forensic methodologies aiming to document and represent violent bordering practices, as well as legal strategies seeking accountability for them. Heller further engages in dialogue with humanitarian and human rights organisations, international organisations, as well as policy makers within different institutions and countries.

As part of the Forensic Oceanography project Heller co-authored a number of human rights reports, including "Report on the Left-to-Die Boat" (2012); “Death by Rescue” (2016) ; “Blaming the Rescuers” (2017); "Mare Clausum" (2018) and “The Nivin” (2019), which have contributed to strategic litigation and have had a major impact within the fields of migration and border studies, nongovernmental politics and the public sphere. The videos and other visualisations based on these investigations have been shown in a broad range of academic and activist contexts, and exhibited internationally, including at the HKW in Berlin, the Venice Biennale, the MACBA in Barcelona, the MOMA in New York, the ICA in London and Manifesta 12 in Parlermo. Based on this research, Heller has published and lectured internationally on the transformations of the Euro-Mediterranean border regime, the ambivalent politics of legal and aesthetic practice and nongovernmental politics at sea. His research has been published in several edited volumes and in a number of international journals such as Mobilities, Revue Européenne des Migrations Internationales, American Behavioral Scientist, Antipode, ACME, New Geographies, Science, Technology, & Human Values Spheres, Global Media and Communication, Cultural Studies, Postcolonial Studies, South Atlantic Quarterly. Heller co-edited with Lorenzo Pezzani and William Walters the book Viapolitics: Borders, Migration, and the Power of Locomotion (Duke University Press, 2022).

In the aim of scaling up and consolidating the critical forensic approach developed within the Forensic Oceanography project and adapt its methods to other contexts and modalities of border violence, in 2021 Heller co-founded the Border Forensics research and investigation agency, based in Geneva, for which he acts as Director of Research. Border Forensics develops new methods to investigate the continuum of violence experienced by migrants as they attempt to cross Europe’s disseminated borders, from the increased danger they face as they cross the desert of Niger as a result of outsourced border control to the violent intersection of state borders and racial boundaries they encounter within European cities.

Heller’s current research project, the “Circumference of Violence research” focuses on the transformation and normalization of violence across the external borders of the EU, despite the tireless efforts of nongovernmental actors in exposing and seeking accountability for border violence. The project explores the following overarching question: How do the practices of different actors at the border, as well as political and legal processes across different scales – local, national and European – shape changing modalities of border violence? To answer this question, the project focuses on four case studies located across the circumference of the EU external borders – from Spain to Poland - which it analyses comparatively and relationally through anthropological and geographic approaches and critical forensic investigative methods.

The Circumference of Violence - Tracing the normalisation and brutalisation of violence across Europe’s shifting external borders

Project leader:
Charles Heller, Institute of Social Anthropolgy, University of Bern,

Project description:
The mobility conflict (Heller and Pezzani 2018) that emerges from the opposition between the dynamics of migration from the global South to the EU’s restrictive migration policies targeting them structurally generates conflictual and violent encounters between border guards and illegalized migrants. These reach their maximum intensity and lethality along the external borders of the EU. Between 1993 and 2021 48.647 migrant deaths have been recorded at the borders of Europe (United 2022). The majority has occurred during the crossing of the Mediterranean and are the result of forms of indirect violence in which state actors tailor their practices to evade the sanction of the law. Migrant deaths – one of the manifestations of border violence – have thus become an enduring and almost daily outcome of the way the EU’s maritime borders work. While migrant deaths are denounced and opposed by some actors, these are minoritarian, and deaths have come to be normalised. At the same time, in the wake of the 2015 “migration crisis”, an increasing number of deaths and violations have been documented at other EU external land borders – such as those cutting across the Balkans. These have mostly involved forms direct violence, in particular during push-backs - when migrants are force back over a border - perpetrated with a blatant disregard either for human dignity or legal norms. Following Mbembe (2020) we can describe these cruel and uninhibited practices as involving the brutalisation of bordering practices (Hänsel et al. 2022). Extensive civil society documentation, litigation and advocacy concerning these violent practices have not brought them to an end. With regard to the management of migrants, we are seeing a widening gap between the EU’s formal commitments to human rights and practices that violate them. These practices point to increasing disjunctures in the spatiality of state territory, control, law and rights (Shachar 2020).

In the face these both disturbing and perplexing trends, this project explores the following overarching question: How do the modalities of violence/violations against migrants at the external borders of Europe differ in space and time, and what are the practices of and interactions between actors at the border, geophysical conditions, and multi-scalar political and legal processes that enable or limit the normalisation and brutalisation of border violence/violations?

To answer this question, this project primarily draws from geography and anthropology and adopts a qualitative comparative research design combining thick description of the practices of actors at the border and an emphasis on the way they are shaped by distinct geophysical conditions and multi-scalar political and legal processes. Covering the period 2024 – 2028 while locating it in a broader trajectory of change, the research will focus on four case studies located across the circumference of the EU external borders – Spain, Italy, Greece, Hungary.

The empirical analysis will be conducted through two inter-related methodological angles. First we will analyse the practices and interactions between actors directly engaged in perpetrating or contesting border violence in the selected border zones (migrants, border agents and NGOs). Second, Based on the findings generated through this first angle, we will trace backwards the multi-scalar (mainly national and EU) political and legal processes shaping these localized practices. The forensic reconstruction of cases of death and violations will cut across these two methodologies, since on the one hand it will offer fine-grained reconstruction of the practices of violence and the actors involved and, on the other hand, by collaborating with human rights actors to seek accountability we will be able to analyse how they strategise and operate in different policy and legal forums.

Ultimately, the research contributes empirically and theoretically to a better understanding of the conflicts surrounding borders and transnational mobility, the transformation of social and legal norms and violence, and the shifting spatiality of state territoriality, law and rights. It will contribute to bridging the disciplinary boundaries that mark the field of migration and border studies, in particular the gap between the analysis of policy making and implementation as well as judicial control. Beyond its academic contribution, the analysis will help guide civil society and policy makers in identifying nodes of intervention to durably bring border violence to an end.

More information: https://data.snf.ch/grants/grant/218288